One Dollar Allowance

Social security was signed into law by President Roosevelt in 1935. One of the intents of the program was to provide income for retired workers aged 65 or older. The purpose of the Social Security Act was to help destitute aging individuals who were not receiving regular income. The program calculations have changed a bit over the years, but the purpose has remained the same: provide a minimum income to aging individuals, not to provide a source meant as your sole income stream.

Today, most of the United States workers pay into social security through a 6.2% payroll withholding; such withholding ceases once you make $160,200 or more (in 2024). An individual’s year of eligibility is based on their birth year, rather than being exactly 65 years old like it was originally, and is called the normal retirement age. Additionally, there are penalties for filing early and bonuses for filing later than your normal retirement age. The year you file for social security has implications on your income, which I’ll cover later.

CALCULATING SOCIAL SECURITY RETIREMENT INCOME

Social security benefits are computed based on an individual’s highest 35 years of indexed income. The income is indexed, or adjusted, to account for inflation over the years. If you made $10,000 in 1985, that equates to making about $25,000 in 2022. I mention that it’s in year 2022 and not today because indexing applies to all income older than the last two years, while the most recent years are taken at face value. Indexing ensures that your future benefits account for inflation to make them fair and equitable in the year you need that income, and makes all of the annual salaries of your working years comparable.

Once the indexed total is known for all working years (up to the highest 35 years worth), the totals are added together and divided by the total number of months worth of earnings. The average monthly earnings amount is then used to calculate the primary insurance amounts (PIA). The PIA is the amount paid out monthly if an individual waits until their normal retirement age, which is a table published by the Social Security Administration (SSA) and is based on birth year.

According to the SSA website, an individual who first becomes eligible for old-age insurance benefits or disability insurance benefits in 2024, or who dies in 2024 before becoming eligible for benefits, his/her PIA will be the sum of: (a) 90 percent of the first $1,174 of his/her average indexed monthly earnings, (b) 32 percent of his/her average indexed monthly earnings over $1,174 and through $7,078, and (c) 15 percent of his/her average indexed monthly earnings over $7,078. The percentages are based in law, but the dollar amounts, which are called ‘bend points,’ are updated annually based on the national average wage index. These bend points ensure the program weights benefits to lower income earners, and phases out benefits as an individual’s income increases.

Here’s an example that shows how the bend points are used to calculate the PIA, which is the monthly benefit amount that would be paid out to someone who retires at their normal retirement age and is eligible to receive 100% of their PIA. The monthly indexed earnings over the life of their 35 year career was $10,000. The bend points are applied to each bracket of income up to their max of $10,000, and then the bend points are added together. The total is rounded to the nearest dime though.

If you draw before the normal retirement age, but no earlier than 62, the PIA is reduced by as much as 30%. If you draw after your normal retirement age, the PIA is increased by 8% per year, until you reach 70. In the above example, the earner who made $10,000 a month average over the course of their career will receive ~$3,383 a month if they file for social security benefits at their normal retirement age (in 2024 numbers). If they chose to draw at 62, they’d receive 30% less of their PIA, equating to approximately $2,368 per month. However, if they chose to draw later than their normal retirement age, they would receive more than their PIA (with the amount depending on their normal retirement year).

As you can see, social security is not intended to replace your pre-retirement income. It is meant as a safety net to ensure some level of financial security. If you’d like to live a more lavish retirement, you need to plan ahead with additional sources of income/savings to draw from (e.g., retirement plans like a 401k, Individual Retirement Account (IRA) contributions).

WHEN TO DRAW

We recently heard a conversation where someone told another person that they should definitely claim as soon as possible. However, if you’re not in a situation where you absolutely need that income per month, it’s best to wait. Once you draw, you lock in that dollar amount, save for cost of living adjustments as authorized. Cost of living adjustments for inflation, or COLAs, are based on the Consumer Price Index and announced annually in October.

The year you draw is based on your outlook on your life expectancy, your income need based on lifestyle, and your other income sources. This isn’t a decision you need to make at 35, but you should be watching and planning this over the course of your life. If you’re in good health and active at 62, and have saved enough to live off other funds or are still working, it likely wouldn’t be in your best interest to claim social security benefits.

If you’re born in 1960 or later, your normal retirement age is 67. At 67, you get 100% of your PIA. If you file at 62, which is the earliest you can file, you get 70% of your PIA. If you wait to file until after your normal retirement age, then you get 8% each year until 70. On the graph above, I used a PIA of $3,500 to determine the values for the example. You can see that if you were to file at 62, your cumulative income line over the rest of your life time is a flatter line. You’re receiving a smaller benefit, so it’s adding up slowly. Where the lines intersect is how you’ll determine your break-even draw year. For instance, if you think you’ll live until at least 77, then it’s not worth doing an early draw at 62 because a draw at normal retirement age will provide you more income over the course of your life. If you think you’ll live past 81, then deferring your social security filing until 70 yields the most lucrative scenario.

RETIREMENT AND WORKING

There are stipulations associated with claiming benefits and still working, which is another factor to consider when drawing social security. If you’re 62 and still working, then it may not be in your best interest to collect social security. While you can still work while claiming social security, the SSA may reduce your benefits. The SSA reviews income earned against benefits paid out, and may adjust if there was employment income in the previous year (i.e., income based on pensions or other retirement benefits does not constitute current employment income).

If you are under normal retirement age for the entire year, the SSA deducts $1 from your benefit payments for every $2 you earn above the annual limit, which is $22,320 in 2024. In the year you reach normal retirement age, the SSA deducts $1 in benefits for every $3 you earn above a different limit, which is $59,520 in 2024. It’s likely you don’t “need” that money because you’re still working, your benefit isn’t increasing like it would if you deferred, and you’re actually receiving less money in benefits than based on the normal formula.

SUMMARY

There is no hard and fast rule on when to draw these benefits. The point is to be educated on your options. We don’t recommend you rely on someone else’s opinion on the matter or how it worked for them, as each person’s variables are different. Generally, if you’re in good health and still producing income, drawing on the social security benefits earlier than normal retirement age isn’t going to be your best financial move.

As is the case with most personal finance topics, having diversified income sources in retirement, regardless of what age that is, will set you up to make decisions absent emotion and desperation, and for the betterment of your entire financial picture. Utilize your 401k and all available match, your IRA, your taxable savings, and perhaps your pension, so that Social Security is just one more tool in your financial picture, rather than the only one.